top of page

Annuity Rescue Options and Review

  • Writer: LIR TEAM
    LIR TEAM
  • Dec 6
  • 4 min read
Orange life preserver in blue water with yellow text "ANNUITY RESCUE." Safety theme conveyed through vibrant colors and text.

Why Independent Analysis Matters More Than Ever


More and more consumers—and increasingly financial professionals—are discovering that annuities often perform very differently from how they were sold. At LifeInsuranceReview.com (LIR), we are seeing a growing number of clients referred to us for help, especially those who purchased Fixed Index Annuities (FIAs) 10 or more years ago and are now just exiting or recently exited their surrender period.


Unfortunately, many are disappointed with the results.


And almost every one of these cases could have been avoided if the client or their advisor had used a Licensed Life Insurance Analyst to provide an independent second opinion before or shortly after the annuity was placed.


The Hidden Problem: Most People Don’t Know Licensed Life Insurance Analysts Exist

Unlike agents, brokers, or financial advisors, a Licensed Life Insurance Analyst (a rare license recognized in states like California) is an independent, fiduciary-level expert who:

  • Does not work for anyone but you

  • Reviews life, annuity, disability, and long-term care (LTC) insurance products

  • Is legally authorized to analyze, explain, and critique policies for a fee


Most consumers—and surprisingly, most professionals—have never heard of this license.


This lack of awareness leads to people being sold annuities that don’t meet their needs, are misunderstood, or underperform dramatically compared to the expectations set at the point of sale.


That’s why partnering with LifeInsuranceReview.com (LIR) is essential for professionals looking to protect clients—and themselves—from future problems.


Why So Many Fixed Index Annuities Disappoint

FIAs were marketed heavily with the promise of:

  • Protection against losses

  • Upside participation

  • Reasonable caps

  • No direct fees to the policyholder

  • Safe, stable retirement growth


But here’s the reality many clients face:


Annual Cap Rates Are Reduced—Even When Interest Rates Rise

Insurance carriers frequently lower cap rates, sometimes dramatically.Even in environments where interest rates increase, policyholders often see:

  • Lower caps

  • Reduced participation rates

  • Changing crediting methods

  • Minimal real growth


This creates a mismatch between the original sales illustration and the actual performance, which is why so many clients nearing their 10-year surrender mark discover:

“This annuity did not grow the way I thought it would.”

For many, it’s the first time anyone has reviewed the contract since it was delivered.


The Missed Opportunity: The 10–30 Day Free-Look Period

The free-look window—typically 10 to 30 days depending on the state—is the consumer’s best protection.


During this period:

  • You can review the annuity contract

  • Understand caps, participation, and limitations

  • Evaluate income riders

  • Confirm the actual crediting strategy

  • Exercise your right to cancel the policy without penalty


But most agents, brokers, and advisors do NOT encourage clients to seek an independent review.

This leads to decades-long consequences. It's why it's so important to know your annuity rescue options and get your policy independently reviewed.


Annuity Rescue Options and Review

Even if an annuity has underperformed, there are strategies available.At LIR, we evaluate the following Annuity Rescue Options:


1. Full Independent Annuity Audit (Most Recommended)

A Licensed Life Insurance Analyst reviews:

  • Contract terms

  • Crediting methods

  • Cap/participation history

  • Riders and hidden fees

  • Performance expectations vs. reality

  • Suitability based on client age, goals, liquidity, and risk


This determines whether the annuity is worth keeping, modifying, exchanging, or surrendering.


2. Annuity 1035 Exchange (If Suitable and Beneficial)

If appropriate and in the client’s best interest, a 1035 exchange can move annuity value into:

  • A better annuity

  • A product with stronger caps or fixed rates

  • A simplified, lower-cost solution

  • A strategy aligned with income needs


We evaluate whether the exchange actually creates value or simply restarts a new surrender period with no real improvement.


3. Keep the Contract but Change Allocations

Many consumers don’t realize they can:

  • Adjust indices

  • Move to a fixed bucket for stability

  • Rebalance crediting methods


This may strengthen performance without replacing the contract.


4. Evaluate Riders (Income, Bonuses, Guarantees)

Some riders may be:

  • Worth keeping

  • Overpriced

  • No longer aligned with the client’s situation


A rider analysis determines whether it makes sense to continue, modify, or discontinue.


5. Partial Surrender or Systematic Withdrawals

For clients exiting their surrender period, we analyze:

  • Liquidity needs

  • Market alternatives

  • Tax implications

  • Income planning strategies


Sometimes taking withdrawals and reallocating funds elsewhere is the optimal move.


6. Suitability & Compliance Review (When Needed)

In cases where the annuity appears to have been misrepresented, we can provide:

  • A professional written review

  • A suitability analysis

  • Documentation of discrepancies


This is often requested by attorneys, CPAs, or financial planners.


Why Professionals Refer Clients to LIR

Attorneys, CPAs, fee-only planners, and even insurance agents refer their clients to LifeInsuranceReview.com because:

  • It protects clients

  • It protects the professional

  • It strengthens long-term relationships

  • It avoids disputes and complaints

  • It ensures compliance and transparency

  • It gives clients true confidence in the products they own


Many issues we uncover were entirely avoidable.If the client had received an independent second opinion before buying, they would have made better decisions—or walked away from unsuitable products.


Conclusion: Every Annuity Deserves an Independent Review

Whether you are a consumer or a financial professional, annuities are complex long-term contracts. They require expertise beyond sales presentations and hypothetical illustrations.

A Licensed Life Insurance Analyst provides clarity, transparency, and professional evaluation—without conflicts of interest.


Partnering with LifeInsuranceReview.com (LIR) ensures every client receives:

  • A true independent second opinion

  • A detailed annuity audit

  • Objective recommendations

  • Education on their options

  • A path forward—whether that means keeping, modifying, or replacing the annuity


No one should ever own an annuity they don’t fully understand or that doesn’t align with their goals.


FAQs — Annuity Rescue Options & Reviews

1. What is an Annuity Rescue Review?

A comprehensive, independent evaluation of your annuity’s performance, fees, crediting methods, and suitability—performed by a Licensed Life Insurance Analyst.


2. Why do so many Fixed Index Annuities underperform?

Because caps, spreads, and participation rates are frequently reduced by carriers. This often results in growth far below expectations.


3. Can an annuity be changed or improved after purchase?

Often yes. Through allocation changes, removing riders, partial surrenders, or a 1035 exchange—but only after a proper independent review.


4. What does a Licensed Life Insurance Analyst do?

They review, analyze, and explain life, annuity, disability, and LTC products independently—without selling or commission conflicts.


5. Why don’t agents or advisors recommend an independent review?

Because it may reveal issues, inconsistencies, or suitability concerns regarding the product they sold.


6. When should someone request an annuity review?

  • Before purchasing

  • During the free-look period

  • Before the surrender period ends

  • When income needs change

  • When evaluating retirement planning decisions

  • Anytime you feel unsure about performance or suitability

We had a survivorship policy for about 6 years and when I got my policy reviewed, I learned that I can apply for a new policy with another company via 1035 exchange with $1.6M higher coverage and longer guarantee age. This was because I was also a pilot with now more than 900hrs, and that I qualified for the best health rating at some insurance companies. Our original agent never bothered to follow-up with us to explore any other options, except to make sure we were paying our annual premiums.

Steve & Pat L., CA

Subscribe to Our Weekly Blog

Thank you, you're now subscribed to our Weekly Blog :)

bottom of page