top of page

The Real Cost of the IUL “Tax-Free Income” You’re Being Sold

Writer: LIR TEAM
LIR TEAM
3 days ago
12 min read

Indexed universal life insurance, commonly called IUL, is often sold with an appealing promise: protect your family, grow your money, avoid stock market losses, and receive tax free retirement income.


It sounds like several financial problems solved with one policy.


But there is a question that deserves far more attention:

How much are you paying to obtain those benefits, and could another strategy leave you with more money, adequate protection, and fewer complications?


Understanding the real cost of the IUL “tax-free income” you’re being sold requires looking beyond the projected retirement distributions. It requires examining policy expenses, borrowing costs, investment alternatives, and the assumptions that must hold for decades.


For consumers and the professionals advising them, the goal should be a better financial outcome. Avoiding a tax bill is only one part of that outcome.


Life insurance ad with magnifying glass over policy costs, loan interest and opportunity cost, warning of real cost of tax-free income.

The Problem With Selling Tax Benefits Before Showing the Costs

Tax advantages are easy to market because people understandably dislike paying taxes.


An IUL presentation may focus heavily on future tax increases, stock market uncertainty, and the appeal of accessing money without income tax. The proposed solution can appear obvious before the consumer has seen a meaningful comparison.


Yet a recommendation centered on tax savings should answer several basic questions:

  • What taxes would this particular client otherwise pay?

  • What does the policy cost over the same period?

  • What portion of those costs purchases needed insurance protection?

  • What is the policy’s projected return after expenses?

  • What alternatives offer favorable tax treatment?

  • What happens if the policy performs below expectations?


Without those answers, “tax free” is a marketing description rather than a completed financial analysis.


A strategy can reduce taxes and still leave the client with less usable wealth.


What Does a 40% to 50% IUL Cost Actually Mean?

A percentage is meaningful only when its denominator and measurement period are clear.


If someone says an IUL “costs 40% to 50%,” ask:


Forty to fifty percent of what, measured over how many years?


That figure could refer to cumulative charges divided by cumulative premiums, an early surrender shortfall, or a reduction in projected wealth compared with another strategy. Those are different measurements.


It should not be described as the average cost of all IUL policies without supporting data.


A hypothetical example: Cumulative charges equal 45% of premiums

Consider a hypothetical policy funded with $10,000 annually for 20 years.


Assume its detailed expense ledger shows the following cumulative deductions:

Item over 20 years

Hypothetical amount

Total premiums paid

$200,000

Premium loads

$12,000

Cost of insurance deductions

$48,000

Administrative and policy expenses

$20,000

Rider and index strategy charges

$10,000

Total policy deductions

$90,000

Deductions divided by premiums

45%

These figures are invented solely to demonstrate the calculation. They are not a carrier quote, an actual reviewed policy, or an industry average.


In this example, cumulative policy deductions equal 45 cents for every dollar contributed over the measurement period.


That deserves serious scrutiny when the primary sales message is tax savings.


However, it does not mean the policy charges a 45% annual fee or that its ending value is necessarily 45% below contributions. Interest credits, deduction timing, and other policy mechanics affect the result.


It also does not mean all $90,000 was wasted. Part of that amount purchased life insurance protection.


The next step is to determine whether the client could obtain appropriate protection separately and accumulate more retirement wealth with the remaining money.


Why Comparing Policy Costs With Tax Rates Requires Care

Suppose the household in our example has a 15% effective federal income tax rate.


That is substantially below the hypothetical 45% ratio of cumulative policy deductions to premiums. It should prompt questions about the sales narrative.


But those percentages cannot be directly subtracted to prove that one strategy is better.


The 15% figure measures taxes relative to income for a specified period. The 45% figure measures cumulative insurance deductions relative to premiums over 20 years.


They apply to different amounts and different timeframes.


A proper review also distinguishes between:


Effective tax rate: The average tax burden relative to a defined measure of income.


Marginal tax rate: The tax rate applying to an additional dollar of a particular type of income.


Tax treatment of the alternative: Whether returns are taxed annually, deferred until sale or withdrawal, or excluded through a qualified Roth distribution.


A household’s effective rate can be much lower than the tax bracket emphasized in a sales presentation. However, the tax on a particular additional distribution may depend on marginal rates and other interactions.


The correct response is a personalized tax projection.


The question is not whether a policy cost percentage looks larger than a tax rate. The question is how much spendable wealth each strategy produces after all relevant costs and taxes.


The Tax Comparison Changes When the Alternative Is a Roth

An IUL presentation may compare the policy with a taxable investment account while overlooking available Roth retirement accounts.


That omission can materially change the conclusion.


Roth IRAs and Roth 401(k) accounts are funded with money included in current taxable income. Qualified distributions, including earnings, are excluded from federal income tax. Roth IRAs have contribution eligibility rules, including income limitations. Internal Revenue Service


IUL premiums for personal coverage are also generally funded with after tax dollars.


Therefore, the comparison is not automatically “taxable investing versus tax free insurance.”


For an eligible consumer, it may instead be:

A Roth account offering qualified tax free withdrawals versus an insurance policy offering conditional access through withdrawals and loans.


That distinction deserves a prominent place in the recommendation.


Roth withdrawals do not require insurance borrowing

A qualified Roth withdrawal is a distribution of account assets. The owner does not need to establish a policy loan or maintain a life insurance contract to preserve its qualified treatment.


The IUL retirement strategy commonly uses withdrawals of basis followed by loans. Its favorable tax treatment depends on conditions, including avoiding modified endowment contract status and managing the policy appropriately. Outstanding loans can create tax consequences if coverage lapses or is surrendered.


This does not make Roth accounts free of restrictions. It does make their retirement distribution mechanics materially different.


A high income does not automatically eliminate Roth 401(k) access

Direct Roth IRA contributions can be limited by income. Designated Roth contributions to an employer plan do not have the same income restriction.


The employer must offer the Roth feature, and contribution limits and plan rules still apply. Qualified distributions generally require a five tax year participation period and age 59½, death, or disability. Internal Revenue Service


A proposal that dismisses all Roth options because the client “earns too much” needs closer examination.


The Alternative Worth Testing: Roth Savings Plus 30 or 35 Year Term Insurance


For a household whose primary goals are retirement savings and protection during working years, a useful comparison is:


A Roth IRA and/or Roth 401(k), combined with a 30 or 35 year term policy offering appropriate living benefits.


This approach separates retirement accumulation from insurance protection.


The term policy addresses the financial consequences of death during the coverage period. The Roth account holds the retirement assets.


Longer term options exist. For example, many A rated companies lists 30 and 35 year terms among its available durations and identifies a terminal illness accelerated death benefit.

Availability depends on product eligibility, underwriting, and state provisions.


For some households, this combination may provide a better fit because it offers:

  • A clearly identified cost for insurance protection.

  • Retirement savings without mortality charges deducted from the investment account.

  • Qualified Roth withdrawals without policy loan interest.

  • Investment choices appropriate to the household’s risk tolerance.

  • The ability to evaluate insurance and investment performance separately.


Roth accounts still have investment expenses, possible advisory or plan fees, and investment risk. Their results depend on the assets selected and the owner’s behavior.


The advantage must be demonstrated through a comparison, not assumed from the account label.


Living Benefits Are Not Exclusive to IUL

Living benefits can make permanent insurance presentations especially compelling.


Consumers may hear that the policy can help if they become seriously ill and assume they must purchase cash value insurance to obtain that protection.


Some term policies also offer accelerated death benefits.


The details matter. A terminal illness benefit is not automatically equivalent to a chronic illness or critical illness benefit. Eligibility definitions, payment calculations, exclusions, and benefit limits vary.


Accelerated benefits generally allow access to part of the death benefit while the insured is alive and reduce what remains for beneficiaries. They are not automatically a substitute for comprehensive long term care or disability insurance. Questions and Answers on Accelerated Benefits


A comparison should examine the actual rider provisions.


“Includes living benefits” is the beginning of the review, not the conclusion.


A Practical Budget Comparison

Suppose a household can allocate $10,000 annually toward insurance protection and retirement savings.


One proposal directs the full $10,000 to IUL.


An alternative uses a hypothetical $1,200 annual term premium and directs the remaining $8,800 to available Roth accounts, subject to contribution limits and eligibility.

Annual allocation

IUL strategy

Term plus Roth strategy

Total household budget

$10,000

$10,000

Insurance premium

$10,000 into IUL

$1,200 into term coverage

Separate Roth contribution

$0 from this budget

$8,800

Insurance expenses

Deducted within the policy

Included in term premium

Retirement asset expenses

Policy charges and applicable loan costs

Investment and applicable account fees

Retirement access

Policy withdrawals and loans, subject to conditions

Roth distributions, subject to qualification rules

The term premium is a hypothetical budgeting assumption, not a quote. Actual pricing depends on age, health, coverage amount, duration, riders, and other underwriting factors.


This table establishes a framework. It does not establish a winner.


The full analysis must compare actual coverage amounts, investment risk, projected distributions, and benefits remaining for heirs.


It must also show what happens after the term’s level premium period ends.


Term Coverage Has an End Date, and That Must Be Planned For

A 30 or 35 year term policy may cover much of a household’s income replacement need.


During that period, children may become financially independent, a mortgage may be repaid, and retirement assets may grow. The need for insurance could decline.


But that outcome is not guaranteed.


Some clients need permanent protection for estate liquidity, a lifelong dependent, business obligations, or a specific legacy objective. Others may reach the end of the term with fewer assets than expected.


The plan should address:

  • The projected insurance need when the term ends.

  • Whether the household is actually building sufficient assets.

  • Any conversion rights and their deadlines.

  • The cost and availability of coverage later.

  • Whether a combination of term and permanent coverage is appropriate.


Likewise, IUL should not be assumed to last forever merely because it is called permanent insurance. Funding and contract conditions still matter.


Infographic comparing IUL vs term + Roth, showing costs, tax benefits, and warnings; headline says tax free does not mean cost free.

Opportunity Cost Can Be Larger Than the Visible Charges

The hypothetical $90,000 of IUL deductions discussed earlier does not measure the full opportunity cost.


Money deducted from a policy is unavailable to compound for the owner inside that policy.

For illustration, $1,000 growing at an assumed 6% annually for 25 years becomes approximately $4,292.


That is a mathematical example, not a forecast. It demonstrates why the timing of costs matters.

However, the alternative also has expenses. Term premiums and investment fees must be included.


A fair comparison measures the difference in costs and outcomes between complete strategies. It does not compare IUL with an imaginary investment account that provides free insurance and has no expenses.


Opportunity cost can also include:

  • Missing employer retirement contributions because the household cannot afford both strategies.

  • Maintaining expensive debt while funding a policy.

  • Losing liquidity during a surrender charge period.

  • Having less flexibility when income or family needs change.


These tradeoffs belong in the recommendation before the premium commitment is made.


Ask for the IRR Report

A policy’s illustrated crediting rate is not the return on the total premiums paid.


An internal rate of return, or IRR, analysis accounts for contribution timing and the value received.


For an IUL proposal, request:

  • Cash surrender value IRRs at meaningful future dates.

  • Death benefit IRRs at selected ages.

  • Results under lower crediting assumptions.

  • A distribution analysis showing withdrawals, loans, and outstanding debt.

  • A comparison using the same household budget for the alternative.


Cash value, cash surrender value, and death benefit are different measurements. They should not be substituted for one another.


If the proposal emphasizes retirement accumulation, the return on accessible retirement value deserves at least as much attention as the illustrated death benefit.


The Stacked Assumptions Behind “Tax Free Retirement Income”

An IUL retirement illustration can depend on many assumptions working together:

  1. The owner pays premiums as planned.

  2. Interest credits support the projected accumulation.

  3. Future crediting terms remain sufficiently favorable.

  4. Insurance deductions remain manageable.

  5. Loan costs behave as illustrated.

  6. Distributions do not overwhelm remaining policy value.

  7. The owner monitors and adjusts the contract.

  8. The policy preserves its intended tax treatment.


A static illustration cannot reproduce every future sequence of credits, charges, premiums, and borrowing.


Backtesting also requires caution. Historical index results applied to current policy parameters are hypothetical results, not an actual record of policyowner returns.


NAIC illustration guidance distinguishes guaranteed and nonguaranteed elements. An illustration that complies with applicable rules remains a projection rather than a promise. content.naic.org


Ask what happens if the owner receives several weak crediting years near retirement, needs money earlier, or cannot continue planned premiums.


A credible recommendation should explain the corrective actions and their likely cost.


A 0% Floor Does Not Eliminate Losses in Policy Value

The floor generally applies to indexed interest crediting. Policy deductions continue.


A simplified policy with $100,000 of value, no interest credit, and $5,000 of deductions would have approximately $95,000 remaining before other adjustments.


That is why “you cannot lose money” is an inadequate explanation.


At the same time, a Roth account invested in stocks can experience substantial market declines. Comparing it with IUL requires an honest discussion of both types of risk.


The appropriate investment allocation should reflect the client’s needs. The Roth tax designation itself does not determine the risk level.


What Consumers and Professionals Should Require Before Proceeding

Before accepting a recommendation based on tax savings, request a written analysis covering:

Required analysis

What it should establish

Insurance needs assessment

Amount and duration of coverage actually needed

Expense accounting

Dollar costs by year and cumulatively

Tax analysis

Taxes actually avoided under realistic alternatives

IRR report

Returns based on premiums and usable policy values

Roth comparison

Available IRA and employer plan opportunities

Term comparison

Actual quotes and comparable rider provisions

Stress testing

Results when assumptions disappoint

Compensation disclosure

How the recommendation affects compensation

Independent review

Whether the conclusions withstand outside scrutiny

An EA or CPA with relevant experience can evaluate the tax assumptions. An insurance specialist can assess the contract. An investment professional can examine the alternatives.


No single credential guarantees expertise in all three areas.


A qualified team should welcome questions and independent verification.


LIR’s Perspective: Consumer Advocacy Comes First

At LIR, LifeInsuranceReview.com, we believe consumers deserve more advocates and greater accountability.


Our leadership team brings more than 150 years of combined experience to evaluating insurance recommendations, policy designs, and the assumptions behind them.


We work with CPAs, attorneys, fiduciaries, and fee only investment advisors who want their clients to understand what they own and why.


Our work includes reviewing life insurance and evaluating fixed indexed annuities, registered index linked annuities, and variable annuities. When product implementation is separately requested, the role and compensation should be clearly disclosed.


For a consumer primarily seeking retirement savings and temporary family protection, Roth accounts paired with appropriate term insurance deserve serious consideration before committing substantial premiums to IUL.


For a consumer with a genuine permanent insurance need, IUL may warrant evaluation alongside other designs.


The real cost of the IUL “tax-free income” you’re being sold should be demonstrated in dollars, comparisons, and realistic scenarios.


Visit LifeInsuranceReview.com to discuss an independent review before purchasing a policy, replacing existing coverage, or relying on illustrated retirement distributions.

FAQs - The Real Cost of the IUL “Tax-Free Income” You’re Being Sold

1. Do IUL policies typically cost 40% to 50%?

There is no universal percentage that accurately describes all IUL policies. The hypothetical example in this article shows cumulative deductions equal to 45% of cumulative premiums over 20 years. An actual policy must be evaluated using its own charges, funding, coverage, and measurement period.


2. If my effective tax rate is below the policy’s cost percentage, does that prove IUL is unsuitable?

No. The percentages measure different things. It is a reason to investigate the economics, but the decision requires comparing spendable wealth, insurance benefits, costs, taxes, and risk over the same period.


3. Can a Roth IRA or Roth 401(k) provide tax free retirement income?

Yes. Qualified distributions receive favorable federal income tax treatment. Qualification rules apply, and contributions are subject to applicable limits. A Roth account does not require a life insurance loan to make a qualified withdrawal. Internal Revenue Service


4. Is Roth plus term insurance always better than IUL?

No. It can be a strong option when the client needs temporary coverage and retirement savings. Permanent insurance needs, contribution limits, underwriting, investment preferences, and funding capacity can change the conclusion.


5. Is Roth always better than making pretax retirement contributions?

No. The choice depends partly on current and expected future tax rates. An employer match and the value of a current deduction also deserve attention. A sound review considers both Roth and pretax options.


6. Can I buy a 30 or 35 year term policy with living benefits?

Such options exist, but availability and benefits vary. A terminal illness rider does not necessarily include chronic or critical illness coverage. Review the actual contract and rider terms before comparing policies.


7. Can I access Roth money before retirement?

Roth IRA regular contributions generally come out before earnings and can generally be withdrawn without federal income tax or penalty. Earnings and conversions have additional rules. Roth 401(k) distributions follow different plan and tax rules, so the two accounts should not be treated as interchangeable. Internal Revenue Service


8. Are IUL policy loans guaranteed to remain tax free?

No. Favorable treatment depends on policy and tax conditions. Lapse or surrender with outstanding loans can produce taxable income. Loans also accrue interest and can reduce benefits.


9. What does an IUL IRR report show?

It measures a return based on the timing of premiums and a specified value, such as cash surrender value or death benefit. It helps distinguish the policyowner’s economic result from an illustrated interest crediting rate.


10. Should I cancel my IUL and switch to term plus Roth accounts?

Not without a review. Existing surrender charges, tax consequences, health changes, and the cost of new coverage can affect the decision. Compare keeping, modifying, and replacing the policy before taking action.


Educational information only. Examples are hypothetical. Policy availability, tax treatment, and financial outcomes depend on individual circumstances and applicable contract provisions.

"Don't be sold—and don't own a bad policy (life, annuity, disability, and LTC)." 

We had a survivorship policy for about 6 years and when I got my policy reviewed, I learned that I can apply for a new policy with another company via 1035 exchange with $1.6M higher coverage and longer guarantee age. This was because I was also a pilot with now more than 900hrs, and that I qualified for the best health rating at some insurance companies. Our original agent never bothered to follow-up with us to explore any other options, except to make sure we were paying our annual premiums.

Steve & Pat L., CA

Subscribe to Our Weekly Blog

Thank you, you're now subscribed to our Weekly Blog :)

bottom of page